Jews and Sarah Palin

Conservatives debate Jewish antipathy for Palin

By Ami Eden, JTA ·

Forget 2012, Sarah Palin must think she’s headed to the White House even sooner.

How better to explain the former Alaska governor and GOP vice-presidential candidate’s eyebrow-raising comments a few weeks back, when she defended Israeli settlements on the basis that “more Jewish people will be flocking to Israel in the days and weeks and months ahead”? After all, it’s hard to think of anything else more likely to convince American Jews to pack their bags for Israel than Palin taking up residence in the White House.

And that’s just based on what Jewish conservatives are saying.

Jennifer Rubin, who generally blogs and writes for Commentary about the perceived dangers of the Obama administration, has a story in this month’s issue headlined “Why Jews Hate Sarah Palin.” The piece drew a swift rejoinder from former Bush administration aide David Frum, who rejected Rubin’s sympathetic take on the GOP presidential hopeful and argued that Jews would hardly be alone in not liking Palin. Do Jews Hate Palin?

I hate this title. The title should at least be modified to say why LIBERAL Jews hate Sarah Palin as liberals of all persuasions do and perhaps elitist establishment Republicans like Frum.

The debate echoes wider fights among Republicans and conservatives, not only about Palin but also the future of the GOP.

“If one were to invent a political leader designed to drive liberal, largely secular, urban, highly educated Jews to distraction, one would be hard pressed to come up with a more effective figure than Palin,” Rubin wrote in her Commentary article. Jews more than any other group, she asserted, fall in the camp of liberals and conservatives who see Palin as “uncouth, unschooled, a hick, anti-science and anti-intellectual, an upstart, and a religious fanatic.”

This is an ugly liberal media created image of Sarah in order to demean her. She is in fact intelligent and hardly an upstart having served as Alaska governor. She is not in any sense uncouth or a hick nor a religious fanatic, but simply a devout Christian. I am not threatened by her devotion to her faith. It seems to me the more devout a Christian, the more they tend to be pro-Jewish while the most anti-Semitic people are secular leftists. Incidentally why do devout Christians bother liberals but fanatical muslims don’t? Also Sarah is in fact pro-science. It is liberals who are anti-science. See this article: http://sultanknish.blogspot.com/2010/01/why-liberalism-is-reactionary-ideology.html

Rubin also theorized that Palin’s personal life made her “alien to American Jews,” whether it’s her interest in hunting and guns or her decision to have five children and go through with her final pregnancy after learning that she was having a baby with Down syndrome. In addition, Rubin argued, Palin’s being viewed as “more sexy and athletic” didn’t sit well with Jewish women, who have grown accustomed to admiring female politicians who are “modest to the point of frumpiness in appearance and professional style.”

Why should this life be alien to Jews? Doesn’t true Judaism view abortion as an abomination? And why must Jews only be cerebral and not physical, athletic or willing to get their hands dirty? This is another annoying stereotype of Jews.

Frum, who served as a White House speechwriter and had been widely credited for helping to coin the term “axis of evil,” responded with a blog post challenging Rubin on several fronts, starting with the premise that Jews stand out in their dislike for Palin.

“The sole evidence she cites on behalf of her assertion [that Jews hate Palin] is a September 2008 poll in which Jews disapproved of Palin by a 54-37 margin. That does not look like foaming hatred to me, and anyway those numbers are now 15 months out of date,” Frum wrote in a blog post on his Web site, Frum Forum. “Besides: Lots of people dislike Sarah Palin. Palin excites intense support among a core group of conservative Republicans. Beyond that base, she is one of the most unpopular figures in modern American life. She polls poorly among the young, among women, among independents. A plurality even of Republican women regard her as unqualified for the presidency.”

One of the most unpopular figures amongst the left. And with how the media has portrayed her is it any wonder that she polls poorly among those above mentioned groups. However Sarah is one of the most popular figures amongst ordinary folks who aren't susceptible to brainwashing by the liberal media. I’m so sick of Sarah being portrayed as unqualified when the man sitting in the White House is the least qualified and the least experienced president we have ever had.

Frum also noted that Jews have been fond of politicians with larger families than Palin’s (Bobby Kennedy) and ones from humbler beginnings (Bill Clinton). He did, however, say that a major problem for Palin among Jews is “that they — we — doubt her intellectual capacity for the job.”

But Palin’s biggest problem in winning Jewish support, Frum speculated, is that she divides “her fellow-Americans into first class and second class citizens, real Americans and not-so-real Americans.”

“To do her justice, she has never said anything to suggest that Jews as Jews fall into the second, less-real, class,” Frum added. “But Jews do tend to have an intuition that when this sort of line-drawing is done, we are likely to find ourselves on the wrong side.”

I don’t get the impression at all that Sarah views Jews as not being real Americans.

This is just another example of foolish Jewish liberals brushing aside and holding in contempt friends like Sarah while embracing enemies like obama. Is it any wonder we have any friends at all? To the credit of Christian conservatives this attitude hasn’t resulted in their turning against Jews. As a Jew I am very grateful for people like Sarah who have the moral conviction to take a stand in support of Jewish rights to Israel, a very rare commodity. For a people who pride ourselves on being so intelligent, too many Jews don't have the capacity to distinguish between their friends and enemies and more often than not invert the two. Read the rest.