Israpundit:
British Jews and Israelcontinue
Carol Gould, one ot the participants to this debacle, wrote to me as follows “It has taken me four days to recover from this ordeal. At one point I really felt that I would be murdered before leaving the building on Sunday night. What appalled me was the South Bank giving a free dinner afterwards to about forty members of the audience of hecklers — almost all Jews.”
Carol’s website, the CurrentViewpoint, has her own report.
By Marcus Dysch, Jewish Chronicle
Earlier this week I attended three events, on consecutive evenings, which revealed much about British Jews and their relationships with Israel.
One discussed the rising boycott and delegitimisation campaign (Omar Barghouti, Jonathan Freedland, Carol Gould and Seni Seneviratne) debate the value of cultural boycotts at the 2011 London Literature Festival , another looked at support for Israel from the left, and the third was something altogether different, and, thankfully, more positive.
On Sunday I watched my JC colleague Jonathan Freedland bravely attempt to argue the case against cultural boycotts despite overpowering anti-Israel fervour which at times bordered on outright antisemitism.
Although Jonathan and his “opponent” on the night – Palestinian boycott activist and author Omar Barghouti – tried to keep the atmosphere on the panel as friendly as possible, the make-up of the audience meant Jonathan’s case was doomed to failure from the start of the debate – in fact even from before the start.
Taking my seat in the Southbank Centre I watched as familiar faces from the anti-Israel circuit showed up. Piling in one after another were the likes of Tony Greenstein and Deborah Fink, flanked by dozens of anti-Zionist supporters.
Meanwhile I saw barely a single recognisable pro-Israel face in the auditorium. My suspicions were proved right when the Q&A got underway after the panellists’ impressive opening statements for and against the motion on cultural boycotts.
The bombardment unleashed against Jonathan – who had already spoken out against the West Bank occupation and various aspects of Israeli government actions – was as ferocious as any I can recall against a Jewish panellist in recent years. The response to almost every word uttered by his fellow panellist, American author Carol Gould, was just as vitriolic, with the audience laughing, mocking, shouting and at times even hissing as she spoke.
What really struck me – and seemingly shocked Jonathan too – was how little interest the pro-boycotters had in any form of rational debate whatsoever. Practically every audience intervention was less question, more a direct attack on him and/or Israel. Not on Bibi’s administration per se, but on Israel herself.
They were vicious, argumentative, rude, and revealed views which were absolutely and utterly entrenched, without the slightest prospect of yielding as much as a millimetre to the anti-boycott panellists.
5 comments:
What exactly were the pro-Israel speakers trying to accomplish?
Come to terms with it - there is no anti-"Zionism".
And when you are trying to reason with anti-Semites (especially Jewish anti-Semites, who are the lowest form of scum), you are engaging in irrational behavior.
Rally Israel's supporters and destroy Israel's enemies. Stop with the delusional interfaith dialog between Jews and Jew killers.
I am still waiting to for someone to ask Omar Barghouti how he can boycott Israel, while at the same time getting he Masters degree from Tel Aviv University! He who was born in Qatar, grew up in Egypt and only moved to Ramallah as an adult! But I guess anything goes if you are anti-Israel--the low-life hypocrite!
Esther-you are a vicious left wing antisemite posing as a good Jewish woman. I see right through you
I know Esther you are a hundred percent correct.
Barney
this just in. good cISRAPUNDIT
NORWAY ATTACK POINTS OUT AN IMPORTANT TRUTH:
By Ted Belman
While we have been totally focused on Islamic terrorism, we have unfortunately forgotton that the terrorism of the far Right poses an equally dangerous risk to the world at large. Yes, it is extremism from whatever source or direction that can destroy our civilization, and other societies as well. We cannot remain asleep at the wheel. Religious extremists have, with the intention of stopping legal abortions, killed and maimed in North America , Europe and Asia for years. Right wing bigots, have spewed their vitiriol directed at Jews, Moslems, gays, blacks and just about anyone else that does not measure up to their exacting wasp standards. The internet sites of the extreme Right promoting white supremacy and Christian values are constantly increasing.The Nazi and Fascistic philosophy prevalent in the Europe of the 30's and 40's is just one example of Right wing extremism gone wild. The 60 million dead that resulted including 6 million Jews, is a stark reminder that the potential for devastation is always there.
We cannot remain asleep at the wheel.
ommon sense.
Post a Comment